Return to Transcripts main page

CNN Newsroom

Search Continues for Flight Data from EgyptAir Flight 804; Theories of What Could Have Happened Aboard Flight 804; Hillary Clinton Blasts Donald Trump on Guns. Aired 12-12:30a ET

Aired May 22, 2016 - 00:00   ET

THIS IS A RUSH TRANSCRIPT. THIS COPY MAY NOT BE IN ITS FINAL FORM AND MAY BE UPDATED.


(COMMERCIAL BREAK)

[00:00:08] NATALIE ALLEN, CNN ANCHOR: Remnants of a disaster. The first evidence of flight 804 state emerges from the Mediterranean. But the proof of proof of what caused the EgyptAir crash is still missing.

A major objective one in the fight against the Taliban, U.S. officials think they've killed the leader of the Afghan terror group.

And a tale of two candidates, after Donald Trump cozy up to the National Rifle Association, Hillary Clinton spends the evening with the mothers bereaved by gun violent.

It's all ahead here on CNN NEWSROOM. Thanks for joining us. We're coming to you live from Atlanta. I'm Natalie Allen.

An uninflated life vest, a seat, a purse and other personal belongings batted from debris is all searchers have found, so far in the hunt for EgyptAir Flight 804 along with some human at remains. They are still looking for the flight data and cockpit voice recorders which will likely answer many questions.

French aviation officials say the plain sent automated messages indicating smoke near the cockpit confirming the data obtained from CNN scene and these screen shots. The jet was over the Mediterranean heading from Paris to Cairo when it dropped off radar early Thursday morning. CNN's Ian Lee is in Cairo with more on the investigation.

(BEGIN VIDEOCLIP)

IAN LEE, CNN CORRESPONDENT: What investigators are looking at right now is the information that came from the airplane minutes before it crashed. As sensors were detecting smoke in the avionics and lavatory. Could it mean a fire? Possibly. Could it mean something else? They don't know at this moment. To really get a full picture of what happened, investigators tell us they still need to find the fuselage and the data recorders. Those are still in the Mediterranean. They have not been able to locate them at this moment.

But we are seeing parts of the plane being recovered or has been pieces of carpet, a blanket, a pillow. And remember, this was a red- eye flight. So these items could have possibly been in use when the crash happened. There was also a life jacket as well as a purse. But these are small pieces of a bigger puzzle of what actually happened.

The rescue crews are also saying they found body parts. And for families here in Cairo that is crucial. They want to have their loved ones recovered as so that they can give them a proper burial but Egyptian officials are saying that, that still could take weeks. As they need to do DNA testing to make sure the remains get to the right family. So the big theories, right now, two of them, it could it be terrorism or could it be mechanical. Investigators still don't know. The Egyptian officials has that they're leaning more toward terrorism but they haven't ruled out anything yet. This investigation still very much under way and ongoing. Ian Lee, in Cairo.

(END VIDEOCLIP)

ALLEN: Many aviation experts are saying that the flight may have been tampered with prior to take off. But that hasn't led to any clear idea of who might have done it if that is the case at all. Our Tom Foreman shows how long the list of possible suspects could be.

(BEGIN VIDEOCLIP)

TOM FOREMAN, OUR TOM FOREMAN SHOW'S HOST: At the time this plane went down, there should have been two people in the cockpit, five crew members in the cabin, three security people here marked in red and 56 passengers. They all have to be looked at by investigators. But let's sweep this plane back to gate of Charles de Gaulle before it took of and look at this area right around who had access to this. First of all, there were people on the ground who were doing basic maintenance and care of the ground, maintenance crews that to check the wheels, hook up fuel lines, things like that. There are luggage handlers who had to put bags on and off. There were cleaners who have had come on tidy up a little bit. There can be caterers who have to put food and beverage on board. And there were gate agents ready to check tickets and where people are seated.

All in all, easily, 35 people who had access to the plane, direct access on the ground. If you expand it just a little bit, let's say we include the plane next to it or the plane over here, those areas where you have people could walk over in just 100 steps or maybe even less, this number jumps up you can easily triple it to more than 100 people.

And if you go to the whole airport, and everybody who has some sort of security badge here that gets them into a secure place then it goes wild. This number jumps to 86,000 people who have some sort of access at that airport. So we started wondering, what about here in the United States? How many people have a badge that lets them go into some sort of secure zone in one of our airports somewhere coast-to- coast? Turns out last year, homeland security gave us a number. 3.7 million people. That's a lot to keep track of.

(END VIDEOCLIP)

[00:05:10] ALLEN: Tom Foreman reporting for us there from Washington. Alan Diehl joins me now from Albuquerque, New Mexico. He's a former accident investigator with the U.S. National Transportation Safety Board. He's also the author of "Air Safety Investigators: Using Science to Save Lives-One Crash at a Time". Alan thanks for being with us.

I want to as you first as you know as teams continue to search for the fuselage and the recorders. We only have this ACAR's data not for each authorities said backed up showing a cockpit window was open for some reason that's -- then smoke alerts from a front lavatory in the avionics bay, and then within the two to three minutes timeframe, two alerts having to do with flight control computer systems. Are these computer systems in the avionics area and how important is that area to control this type of airplane?

ALAN DIEHL, FORMER U.S. NATIONAL TRANSPORTATION SAFETY BOARD: It is absolutely important. It is the brains of the aircraft dock. The airbus was the first fully automated aircraft to fly year A3 fly I should say in the '88. And that is where every -- that's the central nervous system, if you will, of the aircraft.

So, if things start going wrong in there, if there's heat, fire, et cetera, you got real problems and you could've literally lose control of the airplane because the aircraft is also a fly-by-wire aircraft. The electronic signals from the side stick controllers run through that section, that bay, that avionics bay.

And I also know that the wall between the cockpit and the lavatory, the forward lavatory, is -- it's not armored like the door. It's fairly flimsy. And so smoke could also drift from the avionics bay into the cockpit and then into that lavatory. So, everything is still on the table. We don't know why that smoke was detected in that avionics bay or lavatory. Could have been sabotaged, could be a mechanical failure or so. Everything is very much on the table, at this point.

ALLEN: Well what is protocol or the methods for a pilot and co-pilot when they detect smoke? What would they begin to do?

DIEHL: First thing is you get your smoke mask on. There's one stow at beside your cockpit. Now these are not the kind of masks at the passengers in the back, the yellow things that come down from the ceiling. These are more like the firefighter mask. They cover your face. And when you hit the button it literally inflates the back tubes inflate and hold the goggles, which are integrated into the mask tight to your face. So that's the first thing.

The next thing is you start doing what they -- what we call troubleshooting. They have to figure out what's this -- what's causing this problem. And there are very complex and lengthy checklists. Now these come up on computerized screens. But you're supposed to work as a team to troublesho -- to works through the checklist.

So, a lot of things need to happen in a sequence. The problem is, if you have smoke in the cockpit, we've seen this before, even with the goggles, Natalie, it can cover up the instruments. You literally can't see the instruments that you're using to fly by. So, things can go very bad very quickly if you have a failure like this.

ALLEN: Is there a microphone in these masks for the pilots to still communicate with each other?

DIEHL: Yes Natalie, they use an earphone each mask. Once you put it on, the masks are -- if the mask microphones are hot. So they can talk to each other, of course. And they can select whether they want 100 percent oxygen or just normal oxygen, depending on how much smoke there is -- in the cockpit.

But we've seen before, there was a Swissair McDonnell Douglas jumbo jet that had a cockpit fire and they were complaining when they found the voice recorders, you could hear the pilots -- the co-pilot who is flying saying, "I can't see the instruments." He also lost his transponder and a lot of the automation. Remember, this aircraft or highly automated. And you're -- it's important that you be able to see these instruments, especially at altitudes like 37,000 feet. You don't want to make too many dramatic moves too suddenly that you could've -- you can literally stall the aircraft and have a -- what they called depart-controlled flight, and then you are in deep trouble.

So, this is going to be a lengthy process and not until they find those black boxes, the data recorder and the cockpit voice recorder. We probably really understand this and, as others have said, we need also need to find the wreckage of the E.E. bay or they call it the Electronics Equipment Bag. But that's going to be critical. So then -- the nose of the aircraft is critical, but the tail where the black boxes are located are also critical.

Now the tail with the black boxes has the underwater locator pingers. So, those are good for 30 days. I just hope the Egyptians are getting the support they need. This didn't in Malaysia 370 and we -- the batteries died and so the batteries expired before we found the airplane. But we still haven't found that airplane.

[00:10:06] ALLEN: All right. So, that of course, they want those and list here the pinging hopefully of the Mediterranean Sea is pretty deep, but what will be key to learn? What will you'll be hearing for when they do and if they do recover the recorders of -- what would you be wanting to know about the data?

DIEHL: Well, there are different types of recorders. Obviously one is -- they call it a voice recorder, but it's really a noise recorder. And I can remember, a South African 747 that went down in the western Indian Ocean, they never find the data recorder. But on the so-called voice recorder, they could hear circuit breakers popping in the cockpit. So, both recorders are very critical.

In my book, I talked about the flight data recorder with its hundreds of channels tells you what happened, but you have to kind of listen to the voice recorder to deal with the response of the pilot. So, both are critical.

But Natalie, there's one other thing that I haven't heard anybody talk about on television, and that is the oxygen-- the solid state oxygen generator that's located in that forward lavatory. In 2011, the FAA ordered all U.S. aircraft to remove those oxygen generators for fear that a terrorist could those as weapon. These burn very hot and could be dangerous in the hands of the wrong person. They are literally located I believe in the ceiling of the lavatory of that airbus.

And I don't know if the European authorities, some of them did this. But I don't know if the Egyptians removed those portable or not portable but they fixed oxygen generators from the lavatories. If they haven't done that, I'd sure like the Egyptian officials to acknowledge that.

ALLEN: All right. Well, we'll look into that. And thank you for sharing that information with us and thanks for helping us understand what's next with this search and we hope they find these data recorders. Alan Diehl. Thank you, Alan.

DIEHL: Thank you.

ALLEN: U.S. officials think an air strike has killed the leader of the Afghan Taliban. Mullah Akhtar Mansour was traveling in a vehicle near the Pakistan-Afghanistan border. A U.S. official says the strike probably also killed the second man in the vehicle but it may be days before the deaths are confirmed. The strike was authorized by President Obama.

So, what impact with Mansour's death have on the larger fight against the Taliban? Chief U.S. security correspondent Jim Sciutto got some insight from former CIA counter terrorism analyst, Buck Sexton.

(BEGIN VIDEOCLIP)

BUCK SEXTON, CNN SECURITY CORRESPONDENT: This may keep them off balance for a short while. And it's also -- it should be noted that we're entering the fighting season, we are in the fighting season in Afghanistan and so anything that disrupts their operational tempo is going to be very helpful for the purpose of stability and will help the afghan national security forces perhaps get a stronger footing in some areas.

All that said, there's certainly succession plan in placed. We've seen leadership before killed or just die of natural causes that are at up the heads of insurgencies or terrorist groups like the Taliban without really much of a long term change. In fact, sometimes things get worse afterwards.

So, right now I think there will be a bit of a pause or they're will a pause in some operations perhaps because of the strike. You can also expect senior leadership to probably keep their heads down a little bit more in the Af-Pak border area, but we still have a very long protracted insurgency, a counterinsurgency campaign to wage.

JIM SCIUTTO, CNN ANCHOR: So place this in the political debate for us, does this fight the narrative that the U.S. war on terror is failing? We know that there is a recent CNN poll that shows that most Americans feel the fight against ISIS, for instance, is not working. Does a strike like this on the heels of other successful strikes against terror leaders in Iraq and Syria, Yemen, you name it, does it change that narrative?

SEXTON: I don't think it will really affect perception, Jim, because not that many people, quite honestly know Mullah Mansour is or was, depending on whether he was actually killed in this strike. Isn't somebody who is thought of, for example, having direct ties to 911. Mullah Omar, for example, is someone who is generally better known, obviously, Osama Bin Laden. I mean some of the names that have become more prominent in terrorist lexicon that have taken out in the past, quite affect perception but Mullah Mansour will be replaced with Mullah such and such in a very short period of time.

And so I don't think it will really make much of a difference to how the public views this. I think what does matter is that we still have close to 10,000 U.S. troops in Afghanistan. We've been that war for 15 years and there's no change in strategy. There's no reason to believe we're doing anything differently that would put the Taliban back on their heels. We're still hoping for political reconciliation. We've been hoping for that for a long time.

The Taliban is resurgent this year. The Taliban has actually been taking back territory, so it's really, piece by piece in a very large war, and this is a good day for U.S. special operations, a good day in the counterinsurgency campaign against the Taliban but not a sea change.

(END VIDEOCLIP)

ALLEN: Buck Sexton, former CIA analyst. We turn now to the presidential race. Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump are blasting each other on guns. Like Clinton calls Trump's ideas dangerous. Hear that with given a moment plush a tropical cyclone slams the coast of Bangladesh. The death and destruction left in its wake. We'll hear about that from Derek Van Dam.

(COMMERCIAL BREAK)

[00:16:35] ALLEN: Welcome back. In the race for the white house, Hillary Clinton on Saturday blasted Republican rival Donald Trump on guns. Trump on Friday, accused her of wanting to abolish gun rights. But speaking at a Florida event put on by the Trayvon Martin Foundation, Clinton called Trump's ideas on firearms dangerous.

(BEGIN VIDEOCLIP)

HILLARY CLINTON, (D), PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATE: Donald Trump said that in his very first hour as president, heaven forbid -- he would overturn President Obama's actions to strengthen background checks. Remember, President Obama took those steps after the massacres at Mother Emanuel in Charleston in Sandy Hook Elementary in Newtown, Connecticut.

Then, Mr. Trump went further. He said that, also, on his first day in office, he'd mandate that every school in America allow guns in classrooms. Every school, he said. That idea isn't just way out there, it's dangerous. We are smart enough and strong enough as a nation to figure out how to protect the rights of responsible gun owners, while keeping the guns out of the hands of domestic abusers, other violent criminal, gang members the severely mentally ill. I know we can do this. And despite all the political noise, we are actually united on this issue.

(END VIDEO CLIP)

ALLEN: Donald Trump now faces few hurdles to the Republican nomination. But despite Clinton's insurmountable delicate lead, fellow Democrat Bernie Sanders is still in the race. He's been accused of creating divisions in the party. But speaking in New Mexico Saturday, Sanders said Democrats will prevail against Trump.

(BEGIN VIDEOCLIP)

BERNIE SANDERS, (D), PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATE: Donald Trump will never be elected president because the American people will not support a candidate who insults Mexicans and Latinos, who insults Muslims or women, who insults African-American or veterans. Our job is to bring out people together to create a government that works for all of us, not just the 1 percent and we will never allow people to divide us up.

(END VIDEO CLIP)

[00:20:28] ALLEN: Donald Trump is appealing to evangelicals and Latino voters. He recorded this message more than 1,200 Latinos attending the National Hispanic Christian Leadership Conference.

(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)

DONALD TRUMP, (R), PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATE: We're going to do massive tax cuts especially for the middle class and people that are poor are going to pay nothing. We're going to bring back jobs. You're going to start paying taxes after you're making a lot of money and hopefully that's going to be soon. We're going to stop drugs from pouring into our country. We're going to strengthen our borders. We're going to stop the drugs. I just want to thank the whole group and the committees that asked me to do this. National Hispanic Christian, three great words.

(END VIDEOCLIP)

ALLEN: You can see up-to-date full coverage of the presidential election online. Log on to cnn.com/politics. And ahead here, thousands displaced in Bangladesh following a deadly cyclone. Derek will have that story for you in just a moment.

(COMMERCIAL BREAK)

ALLEN: And welcome back. This is the aftermath of a tropical cyclone that hit Eastern India and left a trail of heavy flooding and destruction as it traveled northeastward. The cyclone made landfall in neighboring Bangladesh Saturday killing at least 21 people. Half a million people there have been evacuated. And flooding will continue to be a major concern. Derek Van Dam her with us to tell us more about it.

DEREK VAN DAM, CNN METEOROLOGIST: You know, the other reason why Bangladesh is so vulnerable to cyclones is because the geography near the coast, right along the sea, is basically at 0 to even 10 feet above sea level. So, it doesn't take much for storm surge to inundate the local cities. In fact, the local meteor logical agency they are saying the storm surge was 0.9 to 1.2 meters, that's three to four feet above the normal tide height.

And now the storm continues to interact with land, it is weakening. But that doesn't mean it's not producing a significant amount of rain, still, on top of what they have experienced so far. I mean look at these pictures, terrible situation going on there. We 21 confirmed fatalities. We do anticipate, unfortunately, for that tall to rise because the flooding continues and the threat for landslides and mud slights will continues into next week as well.

Look at these impressive rain fall totals Northeastern India, over 450 millimeters. Similar rainfall totals into Bangladesh. You can see exactly why we have a flooding event in place at the moment.

Now this is the remnants of what was the cyclone Roanu and you can see that it's really lost the bulk of its strength. But there are still showers and thunderstorms around the rotation here. And that means that any of the slow moving storms could easily another 100 to 150 millimeters on top of an already saturated environment, leaving our threat for flooding to continue.

[00:25:01] You can see for the most part of the forecast radar brings the bulk of the rain over central and eastern Myanmar moves it away from Bangladesh and northeastern India. But that doesn't mean that cyclone-induced thunderstorms can't pop up across this area again because there's still plenty of energy from the cyclone that's move across the region.

Now we're looking at images on the other side of the world. This is from central Costa Rica. We have the Turrialba volcano that has erupted around three times since Wednesday of this past week. This particular volcano is about 50 kilometers to the east of the capital city San Jose. And we have already experienced ash in some of the neighboring provinces and neighboring cities including Guadalop - Guadalajara (ph). I'll show you that in just one second.

By the way, there have been evacuation orders, around 5 kilometer radius around this particular volcano. There are a few remote villages throughout this area. And this is the scene people are dealing with. You can actually see people wearing masks because the air quality index actually been reduced because of the ash in the air and also have been flight delays as well.

Let's get to some of the video you can see exactly what I'm talking about. Here is the actual moments of the volcano erupting of impressive video, to say the least this is the time lapse. There were also extremely loud explosions especially with the third and strongest eruption. This left that blanket of ash in Guadeloupe and Costa Rica. That ash (inaudible) three kilometer into the air, Natalie, and some of again the flights were canceled and delayed as ash obviously is a concern for the aviation industry.

We'll talk about that so many times. And you can see people having to protect their faces and use masks just to continue to keep that ash out of their breathing nostrils and other sorts. So, it's obviously a conserved that area.

ALLEN: My nonscientific thought is that volcano isn't messing around.

VAN DAM: No, it's not. This volcano continues to erupt and looks like it will be active at least for the next several weeks.

ALLEN: All right. Thanks Derek. Well we're going to tell you about a giant massive fuel tank. It might look familiar to many of you. Its stopping traffic in Los Angeles this weekend. This 30,000 kilo tanker is more than 47 meters long it's been taken to a science center where it will go on display with its veteran partner the space shuttle endeavor. We all remember these fuel tanks when they were up against the shuttle at Kennedy Space Center and remember right before launch, they moved that arm back from this fuel tank. And that -- there it is -- there's the arm up there.

VAN DAM: Wow.

ALLEN: That meant that the shuttle lunch was about to get underway our memories and now that fuel tank is taking a whole to go the streets of L.A. that just kind of interesting.

VAN DAM: Is there's going to be traffic delays because of that? I guess I'll take it.

ALLEN: I'll take it. Absolutely, yeah. All right, thanks for watching. Our top stories right after this.

(COMMERCIAL BREAK)