Return to Transcripts main page

CNN Live Event/Special

Bush Speaks on Patients' Rights Bill

Aired July 11, 2001 - 13:54   ET

THIS IS A RUSH TRANSCRIPT. THIS COPY MAY NOT BE IN ITS FINAL FORM AND MAY BE UPDATED.

THIS IS A RUSH TRANSCRIPT. THIS COPY MAY NOT BE IN ITS FINAL FORM AND MAY BE UPDATED.
BRIAN NELSON, CNN ANCHOR: We're going to go to the White House and President Bush speaking about the patients' bill of rights.

(JOINED IN PROGRESS)

GEORGE W. BUSH, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: Thank you very much. It's great to welcome you up from Monroe, Louisiana.

Mr. Secretary -- Madam Secretary. Thank you all for being here. It's good to see members of the United States Congress. Thank you all for coming. My fellow Americans.

We've just come from a great meeting with leaders of medical organizations that represent over 300,000 doctors and specialists; men and women from around our country who are deeply concerned about the state of the practice of medicine; health care professionals that care deeply about not only the practice of medicine but, more importantly, the patients that they see; men and women whose sole life is aimed at improving the lives of their fellow citizens as a result of their brilliant skills.

We had a frank discussion about medicine today and where medicine is headed, and we share a concern that many patients are not receiving the quality of care that we would hope they would receive. And so, we've been debating this issue in Congress: how best to improve the quality of care without unnecessarily running up the cost of medicine, without encouraging more lawsuits which will eventually cause people not to be able to have health insurance.

And there's a good alternative according to the House of Representatives that my administration supports. It's called the Fletcher bill. It's a piece of legislation which says that patients ought to have direct access to specialists.

These men and women who represent specialists all across America has impressed this bill, a bill that my administration supports because of direct access to specialists, and that's important. That's a very important part of the legislation.

I know that there's some talk that the bill that came out of the Senate is the only one that the doctors in America are for. Well, I think if people take a good look and those who hadn't made up their mind yet in the House listen to the voices up here, they will hear there's plenty of doctors who believe that the Fletcher bill is the proper alternative, so patients get the quality of care they need without the fear of losing health insurance, without the fear that businesses large and small might decide, rather than being sued all the time, and, therefore, drop provisions for health care in total, something we don't want in our society.

We want more people covered, not less. And we want the cost of medicine not to be driven up by unnecessary litigation. The Fletcher bill provides safeguards. Now, there's another issue that's important, and that is the external review process. It's an incredibly important part of any medical system or future medical system if we want it to work. And that process basically says, if you're a patient and you and your doctor don't agree with the decisions made by the health insurance company, that you ought to be able to appeal to a panel of doctors. And if the panel of doctors rule in your favor, the insurance company is obligated to move forward. If not, it becomes a cause of action in a court of law.

I just had the opportunity of meeting with Helen Barnes (ph), a nurse-practitioner from Bucks County, Pennsylvania. And thank you for being here, Helen. She was in an automobile accident, and ever since, she's suffered severe muscular problems in her back and her neck. So she and her doc thought that she ought to have a mammoplasty to ease her pain. Her HMO denied her request for surgery. She then appealed the decision to an external medical review process. They ruled in her favor. She took her case to an objective review process, a review panel, and they said she and her doc were right.

And so, she's going to receive the surgery she needs this January. I said, why not sooner? She said because she can't find time to get off work sooner.

(LAUGHTER)

But nevertheless, the process works. And it's so important that we have a tight external review process, one that addresses patients' needs, not the needs of people who want to sue everybody. One that's focused on the patients of America, so that they can take their claims to a panel of experts, medical experts, and have their problems addressed as quickly and as soon as possible. The issue we ought to be discussing is quality of care for patients. That's the whole focus of medicine, and that ought to be the focus of any legislation that comes out of the United States Congress.

And the Fletcher bill that is now being debated on the House floor represents the kind of legislation that my administration can support, that thousands of doctors across America support and, I believe, most Americans will support when they hear the facts and the differences between the two pieces of legislation that are now being debated on the House floor.

I want to thank our doctor friends for being here. I want to thank you for your service to your respective communities. The docs in America are really a part of -- and the medical professionals are a part of really what makes this country great. We've got the best health care in the world -- by far the best health care in the world. And we've got to make sure that any legislation, any laws passed out of Washington enhances the health care for America and doesn't hurt it.

And I believe the Fletcher bill help and enhance the great medical care that we have in our country. Thank you all for coming. Thank you for the endorsement of a good piece of legislation. And may God bless your work and God bless America.

Thank you.

TO ORDER A VIDEO OF THIS TRANSCRIPT, PLEASE CALL 800-CNN-NEWS OR USE OUR SECURE ONLINE ORDER FORM LOCATED AT www.fdch.com